Airline loyalty has never been more strategically important—or more misunderstood. Airlines invest heavily in elite perks, mileage bonuses, and branded program experiences, assuming the biggest threat to loyalty comes from competitors. But the data tells a different story. The real challenge isn’t program cannibalization or status match wars. It’s the millions of members who never engage at all. This “silent majority” accumulates points, rarely redeems, and quietly absorbs both attention and liability. And until airlines create more meaningful, flexible ways for members to redeem, that silence will continue.
Airline Loyalty’s Real Challenge Isn’t Competition — It’s Silence
Airlines pour enormous resources into designing loyalty tiers, mileage bonuses, and elite perks. Those investments assume the primary risk to airline loyalty comes from rival carriers — but the larger risk is quieter and less obvious: member inactivity. Around half of the members in many programs remain inactive or redeem only for low-value economy flights.
That inactivity isn't harmless. With roughly 30 trillion unredeemed points industry-wide, airlines carry a growing liability while simultaneously forgoing ancillary revenue opportunities. The real growth opportunity for airline customer loyalty is not reshaping the behavior of the top 10 percent of flyers; it is activating the silent middle — millions who accumulate points but don’t use them.
Flexible redemptions — hotels, cars, activities, travel protection, and points+cash options — are the blunt instrument for that activation. They give members practical ways to realize value and invite them back into the airline’s ecosystem.
Understanding the Silent Majority Problem
The Silent Middle Represents Massive Untapped Revenue
Large airline loyalty programs follow an uneven distribution: a small cohort of frequent fliers does most redemptions, and a large middle rarely redeems.
This creates a commercial and financial paradox:
-
Dormant members represent missed opportunities for selling hotels, car rentals, activities, travel insurance, and ancillaries
Without activation, airlines not only carry the balance-sheet burden of unredeemed points, but they also cede customer wallet share to OTAs and other travel platforms that monetize the rest of the trip.
Why the Silent Majority Stays Quiet
There are three practical reasons why millions of members remain silent:
-
Flight-only redemptions don’t match member behavior. Many fly too infrequently to redeem for meaningful upgrades or aspirational seats.
-
Redemption friction suppresses action. Inventory constraints, blackout dates, complex rules, and unclear valuations make redemption feel like work.
-
Program structure mismatches traveler intent. Members think in terms of complete trips, not discrete seat inventory—creating an experience gap that keeps points dormant.
OTA Behavior Has Shifted Expectations
Online travel agencies established a user expectation for one-stop trip planning: booking flights, hotels, cars, and experiences in one place. This holistic model sets a behavioral baseline.
Travelers who have been conditioned to bundle components through an OTA expect convenience, choice, and transparent pricing in a single session. Airlines that offer only flight redemptions become a peripheral part of travel planning rather than the hub. This disintermediation lowers engagement frequency and weakens the emotional tie between the traveler and the airline brand.
Why Flexible Redemptions Break the Silence
Flexibility Gives Members More Entry Points Into Engagement
Flexible redemptions multiply actionable moments. When points are redeemable across hundreds of thousands of hotels, car rental locations, and activities, members can use points for a weekend getaways, festival tickets, or a last-minute needs.
This matters because members often have travel intent without having a flight to book. Flexible options convert passive balances into usable purchasing power, lowering the activation threshold. A program member who never had enough miles for a transatlantic award may still find value using points for a two-night stay or a museum pass.
Flexible Redemptions Increase Perceived Point Value
Perceived value drives behavior. If points can only buy a cramped economy seat, they feel limited. When points unlock full-trip components, their practical utility is visible and immediate.
As perceived value grows, members shift from saving points for uncertain future use to spending points on relevant, near-term experiences.
The Psychological Shift: “I Can Use This” to “I Should Use This”
The first low-friction redemption is a psychological hinge. Once members experience a successful redemption, points start behaving like an active currency—not something to hoard.
This shift accelerates habit formation: passive holders become active users, skeptics become planners, and silent members become repeat travelers.
The Activation Flywheel: What Happens After the First Non-Air Redemption
One Redemption Often Leads to Many
Non-air options catalyze ongoing activity. When a member redeems for a hotel or activity, and the experience is positive, they tend to return. Conversion lift after a first non-air redemption can be substantial, and many members who return do so within months. This early repeat behavior is the start of a virtuous cycle: redemption reduces point liability, experiences increase brand sentiment, and positive sentiment fuels more transactions. Airlines that ignite this flywheel see sustained lift in both revenue and engagement metrics.
Introducing flexible redemption options typically correlates with:
-
~37% increase in redemption activity
-
Over 42% of members returning to redeem again within six months
-
Significant reductions in loyalty point liability
Full-Trip Redemptions Create Stickier Loyalty Patterns
Booking a complete trip within the airline ecosystem deepens the brand connection. When the loyalty experience spans planning, booking, and post-booking support, the airline’s role becomes central to the customer’s entire journey. This ownership increases the share of wallet because consumers are more likely to purchase ancillary items from a platform that already handled a meaningful portion of their trip. It also increases the frequency of interactions — members log in to manage itineraries, check upgrades, and explore add-ons — all behaviors that strengthen long-term loyalty.
When the airline facilitates the trip, it becomes the center of the travel experience—not a commodity seat provider.
Repeat Engagement = Higher Revenue + Lower Liability
Activated members change the airline’s financial profile. Frequent redeemers burn points faster, lowering outstanding liabilities. They also spend more on paid ancillaries and third-party products facilitated through the airline, increasing non-ticket revenue. From a unit economics standpoint, the cost of servicing engaged members is often offset by higher ancillary take rates and improved retention, making activation a net-positive investment over time.
How Flexible Redemptions Turn Silent Members Into High-Value Travelers
More Redemption Options = More Moments to Engage
Each hotel search, car reservation, or experience browse is a micro-conversion opportunity. Instead of losing these moments to OTAs, airlines can capture intent within their experience to cross-sell and personalize offers. These micro-moments aggregate into significant engagement over time; a member who books a hotel and later buys a rental car is more likely to use the airline for future travel-related purchases.
Dynamic Packaging Supercharges Engagement
Dynamic packaging simplifies decision-making and increases average order value. For infrequent flyers or family travelers, this convenience and clarity of bundled pricing is especially compelling.
Points+Cash Opens the Door to the Entire Loyalty Base
Not every member has a large point balance, and that constraint historically limited redemption participation. Points+cash addresses that barrier by allowing members to stretch their holdings and experience the satisfaction of redeeming. This inclusivity converts “not enough” into “enough,” widening the active base and increasing short-term revenue while lowering the perpetual liabilities of unused points.
Personalized, AI-Powered Offers Make Engagement Habit-Forming
AI and predictive analytics enable highly targeted, timely offers that convert passive members into active planners. Predictive signals — travel intent inferred from browsing, seasonality, past behavior, and churn risk scores — let airlines present relevant redemptions precisely when members are most likely to act. This personalization reduces friction and increases the perceived relevance of offers, thereby improving conversion and encouraging repeat behavior.
Removing Barriers to Member Activation
Airlines don’t need to build new infrastructure to unlock flexible redemptions. A marketplace model lets them offer hotels, cars, activities, and insurance directly inside their branded experience, accelerating engagement without long development timelines.
When paired with reliable post-booking support, these redemption experiences become loyalty moments that strengthen trust, reduce friction, and encourage repeat behavior.
Creating Stickier Airline Loyalty Through Flexible Redemptions
Airlines already have the raw material for loyalty growth: millions of members. The challenge is activation. Flexible redemptions are the most direct lever to engage members, reduce balance-sheet liabilities, and reclaim revenue currently leaking to OTAs. The quiet travelers are not indifferent; they simply haven’t been given a compelling, frictionless reason to act. Provide that reason, and the silence ends.
Give your members redemption options they’ll actually use — and unlock new revenue in the process. Contact Switchfly to schedule a demo and see how dynamic packaging can enhance your loyalty strategy today.
